TUESDAY, 17 NOVEMBER 2020 | Nina Klein

Alternatives to Knee Surgery

Loud crunching when climbing stairs, chronic pain and constant swelling: osteoarthritis in the knee is a very uncomfortable type of pain. If you suffer from knee problems like the ones described, knee surgery is one option. But is that really always necessary? What therapeutic alternatives are there? In this post, we'll give you a few options that might help with your knee pain.

What are the Alternatives to Knee Surgery?

Knee pain caused by osteoarthritis is a serious disease and needs therapy. Surgery to replace the knee entirely or partially is a common therapeutic measure.

A full knee replacement is like a resurfacing of the bones in the knee: the end of the femur (thigh bone), the top of the tibia (the thicker of the two bones in the shinbone), and the inward-facing surface of the patella or kneecap. The surgeon removes the bony surfaces and replaces them with metal and plastic implants.

The plastic serves the same purpose as the cartilage and helps the implants slide smoothly against each other.

A complete knee replacement is achieved through a very invasive procedure, which results in relatively long regeneration times and can be associated with side effects. For many patients, however, surgery can improve mobility and quality of life over a longer period.

There are constant innovations in the field of knee replacement surgery. For example, more and more surgeons are using a local anesthetic during the procedure, which can mean a shorter hospital stay compared to procedures which employ general anesthesia.

Even so, this surgery remains a very invasive method with a long rehabilitation period, and not all patients require this type of therapy.

Operations on the Knee: When Are They Necessary?

Does an operation always have to be carried out? Knee replacement is a potential treatment option, and in many cases it is the appropriate one. Some patients cannot undergo knee replacement surgery for various reasons. In other cases, a surgeon may consider a patient too young for a knee replacement, because an artificial joint has a limited lifespan and a further operation may become necessary later in life.

For these reasons, for some patients, alternatives to surgery may be a better solution.

Lose Weight to Reduce the Stress on your Knees

Reducing the load on the knee joint is a recognised part of conservative osteoarthritis care and may help ease knee pain. This requires reaching and maintaining a healthy weight.

Extra weight puts pressure on the knees, adding stress to the joint, increasing pain and making exercise difficult. Research compiled by the Johns Hopkins Arthritis Center indicates that being overweight increases the risk of developing knee arthritis and is associated with faster degeneration of the cartilage that cushions the joint.

Physiotherapy and low-impact exercises

To increase strength and mobility in the knees, so-called low-impact exercises may help. Strengthening the quadriceps and thigh muscles in the leg can support pain relief and range of motion. Examples of regular low-impact exercises are cycling or running on a treadmill.

Physiotherapy can also help. A physical therapist can work with you and put together a customized program that aims at the best outcome for you.

Cortisone and Hyaluronic Acid Injections

Cortisone and hyaluronic acid injections are established options in the conservative management of knee osteoarthritis. Clinical research indicates they may reduce pain for a limited period, usually a few months, which can help you stay on your feet and postpone surgery. They do not offer a long-term solution, and whether an injection is suitable depends on the individual case.

Cellular Therapies for Knee Pain

Cell-based approaches are a newer area of interest in the context of degenerative changes of the knee. Research has identified regenerative and immunomodulatory properties of mesenchymal stem cells, and there is growing scientific interest in the factors these cells secrete – their secretome. Research suggests that a substantial part of the activity associated with mesenchymal stem cells may be mediated by these secreted factors, which may support anti-inflammatory and regenerative processes. Different preparations are used in this context, including bone marrow concentrate (BMC) and intravenous stem cell secretome preparations. ANOVA applies these approaches in selected patients following an individual medical assessment. Stem-cell-based and secretome therapies remain developing medical approaches whose available evidence varies by indication, and individual outcomes cannot be predicted. We have summarised the current state of research in a separate article: Does Stem Cell Therapy for knees work?

Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures

Arthroscopic surgery is a minimally invasive type of knee surgery that is performed with a camera inserted through a small incision. The surgery can be performed to repair a torn cartilage or meniscus in the knee, or to remove fragments of bone or cartilage. Depending on the underlying findings, this type of surgery may delay the need for knee replacement surgery in some patients; whether it is suitable has to be assessed individually.

Another option is an osteotomy. This is a surgical procedure in which the surgeon makes an incision in your shinbone or thighbone to divert the load away from the arthritic area of ​​the knee. This is usually recommended to younger patients with deformities or damage on only one side of the knee. While this is viewed as an alternative to knee replacement surgery, osteotomy can make it difficult for patients to undergo successful knee replacement surgery at a later time if necessary.

Cartilage Regeneration

For knees with incipient arthritis, it may be possible to replace the degenerated cartilage rather than the entire joint. There are several cartilage regeneration techniques that you can consider and discuss with an orthopedic surgeon.

In the case of autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI), for example, a sample of your cartilage cells is taken, grown in a laboratory and then surgically transplanted into your knee. This procedure is not the best option for every patient, but young people and athletes affected by cartilage loss could potentially benefit from it.

Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA) for Knee Pain

If all other methods don't relieve your knee pain caused by osteoarthritis, other options still exist. Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) destroys the sensory nerves in the knees that carry the pain signal from the knee to the brain. RFA, while invasive, is only a temporary solution because the nerves can grow back and the pain can return in six months to two years.

Drug Therapies

Current treatment guidelines are restrictive about the use of opioids in knee osteoarthritis. Opioid painkillers carry a risk of dependence, and clinical studies comparing them with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have not shown a superior long-term effect on knee pain.

NSAIDs have a different risk profile, but they are not suitable for everyone and should be used with care. Even over-the-counter drugs such as ibuprofen can cause side effects, particularly when taken over longer periods. Any decision about pain medication should be made together with your physician.

News & Insights

Patient Services at ANOVA Institute for Regenerative Medicine

  • Located in the center of Germany, quick access by car or train from anywhere in Europe
  • Simple access worldwide, less than 20 minutes from Frankfurt Airport
  • Individualized therapy with state-of-the-art autologous stem cell products
  • Individually planned diagnostic work-up which include world-class MRI and CT scans
  • German high quality standard on safety and quality assurance
  • Personal service with friendly, dedicated Patient Care Managers
  • Continuous analysis of scientific data in the field of regenerative medicine